Feathered Quill Book Reviews

 #Bookreview of Smiling Faceless Woman

By: Thomas J. Gebhardt III

Publisher: Publisher Ghoti

Publication Date: August 8, 2025

ISBN: 979-8985716054

Reviewed by: Ephantus Muriuki

Review Date: July 30, 2026

Smiling Faceless Woman by Thomas J. Gebhardt III presents a nostalgic, spooky ride through college life and the question of whether the dead are really gone, all wrapped up in a thriller that will make the reader sleep with the lights on.

At the start of the novel, we are taken two years back to meet Alex, a student who is about to graduate. He has his eyes on the prize and is willing to work for it. He gets tired but still pushes himself to the limit. Behind all that ambition and exhaustion, something is lurking. It waits for him to fall asleep, and just when he is conveniently vulnerable, it strikes, not with a bang but a whisper. It is smart: “almost with a certain level of intelligence… like a voice, a whisper or a mumble, a footstep…” His brain fights it. He begins to think he is paranoid. But the reader knows better; the darkness has already chosen him, and it is only getting started.

The darkness is not just something haunting but an entity that attaches itself to its victims, feeds on their fears and pain, growing stronger the more it stays. Alex has what it feeds on. It is patient and is willing to wait until he has everything to lose. In part two of the story, we see him thinking that his biggest problem is balancing school and his crush, April. She has become important to him, important enough that losing her would break him. But little does she know that he desperately needs help. When he finally finds the help, events will lead to April being unknowingly set up for a collision with something that will turn her world upside down.

Quill says: Smiling Faceless Woman is not a fast thriller but a “creeping” one, not like a shadow you can see but like a breath you feel but never really get to hear. Its suspense doesn’t come from what happens, but from the dread of when the next tragedy will happen. Its tension isn’t in its main protagonist’s entrapment but in the fact that he can’t escape even if he wants to. Gebhardt makes sure that every case is worse than the last and that the twists are not the “gasp-and-drop-the-book” kind, but those that make you go back and reread the earlier chapters only to realize that the story was giving you clues all along. Smiling Faceless Woman is one of those stories that takes the supernatural seriously, not by telling you that a place is haunted, but by showing you. The supernatural has its own headquarters, case files, protocol, and its elements are informed by real expertise. If you enjoy books that make you check your closet before bed or stories whose locations feel like silent characters with their own agendas, waiting for you to walk through the door, then you should consider yourself warned. This novel is already watching your back!

For more information about Smiling Faceless Woman, please visit the author's website at: tjgiii.com/