By: David James
Publication Date: December 13, 2025
Publisher: Trash Panda Publishing
ISBN: 979-8999979940
Reviewed by: Ephantus Muriuki
Review Date: February 5, 2026
Escala's Wish (Tales of Valla Book 1) by David James is a story whose prologue beautifully sets the solemn foundation upon which the whole narrative arc rests. We are taken ten years back to witness the cold, ceremonial judgement of a sprite of the fey realm named Teryn Lightwhisper, whose only crime was helping a child who had strayed through a hidden portal between the mortal world and the fey realm. His story establishes the story's setting as a realm governed by a code of ruthless consequence, one where compassion is an unforgivable crime, and one where every choice one makes begs a precedent.
We are introduced to Escala, the main character through the vivid recollection of our narrator, Wigfrith Foreverbloom, bard of Misty Springs, who conjures her image to a tavern audience, one, as a golden-haired pixie princess of the Court of Dreams and two, as a flawed, deeply curious individual whose attempt to understand mortal love through a single, forbidden kiss leaves her facing a devastating consequence. We see Escala and her friend Rihanna at a hidden crossing between the fey realm and the mortal world. Here, we lean in with the tavern crowd as Escala leans down to plant that fateful kiss despite her friend's warnings. Suddenly, a sharp crack of a branch in a nearby bush, followed by the appearance of a monstrous wolf jerks us back to reality. A brutal struggle for survival follows, leaving two dead and one injured. Here, we are left wondering not just what Escala's fate will be, but the real reason why the wolf was there at that precise, devastating moment.
The story drags us before the merciless tribunal of the court of Dreams where a sentence is passed to Escala, in cold transformative magic- a permanent exile in a foreign body and foreign land, burdened with a paradoxical quest. The ground she is cast upon is literally stained with the memory of her failure. Every threat on her path feels like a threat that aims to ensure that her exile becomes a permanent grave. Here, we are not forced to care for her, rather, our emotional investment gets earned by the heartbreaking scale of her fall, which frames her fight as a classic underdog struggle to survive in a world that views her as expendable. I remember pausing here, not because the pacing slowed, but because the cost of that single choice had expanded so suddenly and so brutally that it needed a moment to settle.
This story is built upon well-structured themes that are not merely decorative or abstract. They rise from lived, painful realities, driving every twist of the plot and defining every character's choice. The consequence of choice is one of them, and it is well rendered to make the reader feel the weight of every decision. Equally, the theme of love is articulated through sacrifice and yearning, deepening the reader's emotional investment and contributing to a rich, resonant and deeply satisfying experience. Personally, I loved the character formulation and intricate dynamics that bring this story to life, ultimately making it unforgettable. Each figure, from the flawed young heroine to the vengeful Morvena, has been crafted with a compelling motivation. Even supporting characters such as Harper and Roedyn have been given room to endear themselves to the reader. I totally believe that it is these characters that the novel's themes are not just communicated but truly felt.
Quill says: Escala's Wish (Tales of Valla Book 1) by David James is undoubtedly the perfect pick by readers who enjoy stories where personal growth, complex relationships and moral dilemmas drive the plot. It is a story that forces one to sit with questions of justice and mercy, as well as a wonder on what the value of a good heart really is, in a world that often punishes compassion.






